When life hands you different, get different.
Category: Modern British History
Paperback: 432 pages
Publisher: Penguin (5 Jun 2008)
ISBN-10: 0141020628
ISBN-13: 978-0141020624
Inspired/Suggested by: A book that has been on my wishlist for ages, I was merely waiting for it to come out in paperback. The first time I saw it in paperbook was while in Edinburgh with work, perfect as I needed something to read on my train journey home. :)
Synopsis: In 1919 a generation of young women discovered that there were, quite simply, not enough men to go round, and the statistics confirmed it. After the 1921 Census, the press ran alarming stories of the 'Problem of the Surplus Women - Two Million who can never become Wives...'. This book is about those women, and about how they were forced, by a tragedy of historic proportions, to stop depending on men for their income, their identity and their future happiness.
My thoughts: This was an interesting look into a topic that is never taught at schools etc in history courses, but the decisions these women made or didn't make affected us and go on affecting us all today. Education, pensions, legal rights and business all had to change to accommodate these women and the lives they created. This study does have flaws, in places it is thin in source material to back up it's suggestions, but for the most part it is a fascinating look at forgotten documents and interviews with ordinary women who realised they just weren't going to get the chance to do what they grew up expecting to - whether they had wanted that future or not in the first place was irrelevant. The sections of the book that were strongest were those which tried to show what the reality of a girl working in a London typing pool was like - I found the figures of how little money working women were trying to live on and just how desperate their existence was heart-rending to read. I hadn't imagined it was a sunny, easy life but I hadn't realised that a large chunk of the population of working women were struggling to keep themselves fed and clothed sufficiently.
I already quoted one of my favourite passages but here's another interesting snippet to whet your appetite:
'The Daily Express ran a headline: 'Problem of the Surplus Women - Two Million who can never become Wives'. The Daily Chronicle responded, 'No such thing as a Surplus Woman'. The Daily Mail rejoined the debate by asserting that 'the superfluous women are a disaster to the human race.' (page 29, along with a picture of one lone man being hunted by packs of ravenous surplus women)
Have you read this book? What did *you* think?